Malta no longer has to worry about the possibility of bearing the responsibility for the Erika case, eliminating the potential liability of up to €1 billion in damages for the environmental pollution caused by the Maltese-flagged tanker which sank off France in December, 1999, causing widespread pollution on the French coast.

A court decision to this effect was understandably welcomed by the chairman of the Malta Maritime Authority, Marc Bonello, who breathed a sigh of heartfelt relief.

"The Erika saga taxed our office quite a bit, as we had to prove that we were not the 'pirate flag' that the French press made us out to be.

"It appeared that the French public actually felt we did not care as the pollution did not affect us here... Of course, this is absolutely untrue. We were very aware of the concerns; after all we have a very vulnerable coastline ourselves."

In September last year, the MMA chairman and executive director, Lino Vassallo went to France and told the French magistrate that, as officials appointed by the government of Malta, they were sovereign and, hence, could not be subjected to the laws of any country other than the laws of Malta.

They had also argued that they were not correctly served with the papers as required by international convention, charging them together with others, for being responsible for the incident.

The French inquiring magistrate did not accept the MMA officials' claims and demanded that they had to go to France for further investigation. They had by then, however, launched an appeal on the issue of sovereignty with the French Court of Appeal.

"We would not allow ourselves to be dragged into a court case when we knew that as a nation, we had the right to act the way we did," he told The Times.

In June 2004, the French Court of Appeal eventually ruled that there was no case against Malta. The French state appealed but the original ruling was upheld last week by the French Supreme Court.

Was this just exploiting a legal loophole?

"As any lawyer will advise you, however morally right or wrong you feel, it is important to use whatever legal means you have at your disposal. We knew we were morally right, but it was dangerous to treat the merits of the case without first going through the formal process of trying to establish whether or not we had the sovereign right to act the way we did.

"The case would have depended on how the issues were viewed by the courts. And there was a lot at stake. We are talking about €1 billion - what would that do to our national debt?" Dr Bonello wondered.

The MMA has insurance but this primarily covers costs incurred in legal proceedings, and would not apply to environmental damage.

The only help in covering the costs might have come from the International Oil Pollution Contingency (IOPC) Fund, administered by the International Maritime Organisation. This fund consists of money collected from the pro-rata contributions of oil exporters, and is meant to cover some of the expenses for cleaning up environmental pollution following a maritime incident.

Dr Bonello was defensive about the Maltese flag, thinking out loud whether some of the criticism "stemmed somewhat from a hidden desire of other member states to win back tonnage which is currently under our flag but which is beneficiary-owned by EU nationals".

"The Maltese flag is an open flag and so we register ships not only that are owned by companies that are beneficiary-owned by Maltese nationals, but also by companies, albeit Maltese ones, that can be owned by people beyond our shores.

"There is a liberal environment in so many sectors; why should shipping be the exception? Just as we sell financial services to foreign companies, so should we have a right to do so in the maritime sector - as long as this is not at the expense of maritime safety. We are a small country and need to make a living out of selling services as we have no raw materials at all, and no one should deny us this right."

During the French Court proceedings, the Malta Maritime Authority was assisted by Dr Franco Vassallo of Mamo TCV together with the French legal office of Renard and Associates of Marseilles.

Sign up to our free newsletters

Get the best updates straight to your inbox:
Please select at least one mailing list.

You can unsubscribe at any time by clicking the link in the footer of our emails. We use Mailchimp as our marketing platform. By subscribing, you acknowledge that your information will be transferred to Mailchimp for processing.